A Florida appeals court has dealt a blow to environmental advocates in Titusville, striking down a voter-approved charter amendment that sought to establish a “right to clean water” in the city.
The Fifth District Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday that the amendment, which was overwhelmingly approved by nearly 83% of Titusville voters in 2022, conflicts with a 2020 state law that prohibits local governments from granting legal rights to any part of the natural environment.
The charter amendment declared that Titusville residents “possess the right to clean water” and allowed them to bring legal action “in the name of the Waters of Titusville” to enforce this right. However, the court determined that this provision directly contradicts the state law, which explicitly forbids local measures from recognizing legal rights to bodies of water.
READ: Florida Power Companies Seek $1.55 Billion From Customers To Cover Hurricane Recovery Costs
“The 2020 state law prevents a local charter from ‘recognizing a legal right to a body of water,'” the court stated in its opinion.
This ruling is a setback for environmental activists who championed the charter amendment as a way to protect local waterways and hold polluters accountable. They argued that the amendment would empower citizens to take legal action against those who threaten the health of Titusville’s water resources.
However, opponents of the amendment, including the city itself, argued that it was preempted by state law and could lead to costly litigation and regulatory uncertainty.
READ: Severe Weather Threat Looms Over The South This Weekend
This case highlights the ongoing tension between local control and state authority, particularly in matters of environmental protection. It remains to be seen whether the proponents of the “right to clean water” amendment will appeal the decision or pursue other avenues to achieve their goals.
For now, the court’s ruling effectively nullifies the voter-approved amendment, leaving the future of environmental protection in Titusville uncertain.
Please make a small donation to the Tampa Free Press to help sustain independent journalism. Your contribution enables us to continue delivering high-quality, local, and national news coverage.
Connect with us: Follow the Tampa Free Press on Facebook and Twitter for breaking news and updates.
Sign up: Subscribe to our free newsletter for a curated selection of top stories delivered straight to your inbox.